Just finished watching the last hour of 2005 Dakar coverage on OLN, ten days after the race’s conclusion. First critique: get new commentators! Jerry Bernardo, who actually travelled with the rally was a New Yorker. Replace him with Nicky Grist. There’s something about having a British voice on the field that just makes the experience seem a little more refined. Jimmy Roberts, who did a little filming on American dunes (no, you’re not fooling me) and who, according to my suitemate Q, usually does golf, needs to go too. He was stiff, and his audible emotional detachment through the deaths of riders José Manuel Perez and Fabrizio Meoni made the memorials sound insincere.
The Dakar organizers always provide their affiliates with excellent cinematography, and this year was no exception. I liked the very hands-off stage coverage which let the terrain speak for itself, but the stories of each stage really did go untold, and a clear sense of the competitors’ strategies never emerged for the viewer. I think that OLN could have done a much better job of this, especially seeing that they decided to delay coverage until the race was completly over.
And that is my biggest complaint. Last year, Speed put on a half-hour of coverage, complete with British commentator, every night of the race. This year, that would have been a full eight hours of television time. OLN gave us only five, none of which was same-day. It was sad to see Meoni interviews in the first few episodes, knowing that he was already dead but the show making no mention of it despite the late air date.
I do have hope, however, based on my experience with OLN’s coverage of the Tour de France. In it’s first year, it had serious problems (though they did have same-day coverage), but every year thereafter it has been improving. As of last year, they got Sundays back from CBS, and it was their second year with live coverage of important mountain stages. I don’t want—or expect—live Dakar coverage, but a half-hour same day summary would be nice. Do a one-hour recap on the rest day and at the end of the rally, and show each of them the weekend which immediately follows. Get people who know things about racing. You need the Phil Liggett and Bob Roll of rally driving. Nicky Grist, with his WRC television experience will play the role of Phil, and I’m sure you could find an American race announcer who can handle rallies to be Bob.
Finally, Dakar is a race of almost certain tragedy. This year, two competitors died; many more were injured. The television coverage shouldn’t exploit the drama, but should make sure it is conveyed. I think that other than Jimmy Roberts’ tone and pacing, OLN handled this as well as could be expected.
They’ve got a six year contract. One down. Overall Score: Good enough, but needs improvement.